Rhodes in the Peak Scenery of 1822 scoffed at the idea, and related the less romantic explanation of a tall man from Offerton occupying the enormous grave in the churchyard. But there are other records to hand concerning Little John. An interesting book about the Stanhopes of Cannon Hall, near Barnsley, Annals of a Yorkshire House by A.M.W. Stirling, gives a full account of investigations made by Stanhope in 1776, he says - 'This famous companion of Robin Hood, who had been a native of Hathersage, was brought up to the local industry of nail making, till his wonderful strength and prowess made him try his fortunes elsewhere. Little is known of his career however till the Battle of Evesham in 1265, when he fought with the rebels under Simon de Montfort, who was defeated. Little John with Robin Hood and many of the Earl's followers were outlawed. They forthwith retured to the woods, and escaping the arm of justice, lived a jolly free life till old age overtook them. Robin Hood died at the age of fourscore and was buried by Little John in Kirklees Park, after which Little John sought out his native village, where he wished to lay his own bones. As he approached the Vale of Hathersage, it is said he remarked that his career would soon be ended, and shortly after he breathed his last. From that time his great bow with some arrows and some chain armour were hanging in Hathersage church, together it is said with a green cap suspended by a chain.

The above was extracted from 'Let These Stones Live' by Martin F.H. Hulbert, with the kind permission of St. Michael and All Angels church, Hathersage.